Will the VMware-Cisco partnership become irrelevant?

The VMware-Cisco relationship started out as a tech partnership but is turning into a war. Which company will control network virtualization and SDN?

VMware is not the easiest partner to have these days.

The company is so committed to being a disruptive force in the market that it apparently doesn't matter if disruption goes counter to the interests of existing partnerships.

After all, if you're a cloud provider running a VMware vCloud environment, you've got to be wondering how VMware Inc.'s entrance into the hybrid cloud market will affect your business. Will the company now take your subscription dollars?

Things aren't looking much brighter for the VMware-Cisco partnership, which lies at the heart of the VMware/Cisco/EMC (VCE) venture. VMware's network virtualization moves could transform the Cisco Systems partnership into a battle for control of the virtualized data center network.

Ironically, the VMware-Cisco relationship was an early indicator of VMware's commitment to network virtualization. VMware was the first major virtualization vendor to run Cisco's Nexus 1000V virtual switch. The Nexus 1000V has integrated well in the distributed virtual switch role, but it merely laid the groundwork for VMware's much more ambitious role in network virtualization. In fact, the Nexus 1000V added credence to the virtualized network concept, which began a natural progression of network virtualization maturity.

Read Keith's Virtualized Geek blog

Keith is skeptical about what VMware wants with OpenStack

What is a crowd-sourced cloud? Think brokers and inexpensive IaaS

Why Yahoo! is still sexy

But VMware has a larger vision of controlling the entire data center with its software-defined data center (SDDC) strategy. That strategy has VMware management software managing and virtualizing not only the x86 server platform, but the entire data center, right down to the network too.

VMware's acquisition of Nicira will lend itself to this total control -- and could make Cisco and other networking vendors irrelevant. Since the Nicira acquisition, VMware has announced its SDN strategy, which includes a hypervisor-based network control plane. VMware (and SDN in general) looks to commoditize the hardware layer of the network stack just as it has the hardware layer of the x86 server hardware. This will be done by abstracting the control plane from the hardware layer.

More on VMware, Cisco and network virtualization

Cisco to investors: VMware is no threat

Martin Casado talks the future of VMware-Nicira technology

Looking beyond the network to the world of software-defined everything

The state of the software-defined data center

By abstracting the control plane, networks can become completely programmable using a hardware-based distributed access layer that is controlled through a virtual management layer. And guess where you'd run this abstracted controller if VMware has any say in the matter? You guessed it: on a VMware-provided network hypervisor that is independent of the vSphere suite. Cisco has taken notice and gone on the offensive against SDN and what seems counter to the path that VMware has chosen for its SDDC strategy.

But for Cisco, taking on that fight will mean swimming against the stream -- i.e., where the larger networking industry is heading. I'd like to hear your thoughts on this shift: Is VMware looking to make Cisco irrelevant?

Email Keith at keith@virtualizedgeek.com.

This was last published in April 2013

Dig Deeper on SDN network virtualization

PRO+

Content

Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

Join the conversation

12 comments

Send me notifications when other members comment.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy

Please create a username to comment.

Will VMware make Cisco irrelevant in the virtual data center network?
Cancel
Vmware SDN solutions reduces the opex and complexity of maintaing the data center where as hardware approach to SDN will require specialist CCIE to maintain it.
Cancel
Irrelevant
Cancel
Larger workloads demand a solid backbone, which need to be scalable and redundant. running protocols which address these requirements while being able to serve security concerns doing DPI (Deep Packet Inspection) and now even doing layer II via OTV does give Cisco in the serious network world an upper hand.
Cancel
LOL, so it used to be "Server Huggers" fighting server virtualization and holding onto their servers. Now that they are all but extinct, we have a new breed, the "Protocol Hugger". How about we all adopt a new way of thinking: No Protocol Religion.
Cancel
Cisco will be still relevant
Cancel
Very good VMware strategy.
Cancel
VMware has yet to demonstrate any real leadership in SDN. Cisco's efforts in Daylight should keep it relevant in the SDN market for some time still.
Cancel
Cisco still provides the best solutions for data access across networks because of its scalability and I do not see VMware doing it alone anytime in the near future
Cancel
Any switches will do
Cancel
If not irrelevant completely, it will disrupt its profit sanctuary which is equally harmful for Cisco.
Cancel
The future of DC is VM
Cancel

-ADS BY GOOGLE

SearchNetworking

SearchEnterpriseWAN

SearchCloudProvider

SearchUnifiedCommunications

SearchSecurity

SearchDataCenter

Close